PIC information

products and process

markets

Articles

Technical Papers

pultrusion vs. traditional materials

vs. structural timber
vs. steel
vs. aluminum

contact us

PIC home page

CFA home page
pultrusions vs. steel


PULTRUSIONS
VS.
STEEL

Unlike Steel which will rust when exposed to weathering and chemicals, fiberglass structural shapes are highly corrosion resistant. Features of both pultrusions and steel structural shapes are compared on a point-for-point basis below.

NOTE: Properties shown for pultruded fiberglass structural shapes are approximate for typical off-the-shelf structural pultrusions.

COMPARE! Pultruded Fiberglass Structural Shapes Steel A-36 Carbon
CORROSION
RESISTANCE
Pultrusions are available in either polyester or vinyl ester resin for resistance to a broad range of chemicals.

Painting required only when exposed to direct sunlight.

Subject to oxidation and corrosion.

Requires painting or galvanizing for many applications.

WEIGHT Lightweight - weighs 75% less than steel.

1/2" thick plate = 4.7 lbs./sq. ft.

Could require lifting equipment to move and place.

1/2" thick plate = 20.4 lbs./sq. ft.

CONDUCTIVITY Does not conduct electricity.

Low Thermal Conductivity 4 (BTU/SF/HR/Fo/IN).

Conducts electricity. Grounding potential.

Thermal Conductivity 260-460 (BTU/SF/HR/Fo/IN).

STRENGTH Pultrusions have a high strength-to-weight ratio, and pound-for-pound are stronger than steel in the lengthwise direction.

Ultimate flexural strength (Fu)
LW = 30 ksi
CW = 10 ksi

Homogeneous material.

Yield strength (Fy) 36 ksi

STIFFNESS Modulus of elasticity
LW = 2.5 x 106 psi
CW = .8 x 106 psi

Will not permanently deform under working load.

Modulus of elasticity
29 x 106 psi
IMPACT RESISTANCE Glass mat in pultruded parts, distributes impact load to prevent surface damage even in sub-zero temperatures. Will not permanently deform under impact. Can permanently deform under impact.
EMI/RFI TRANSPARENCY Transparent to EMI/RFI transmissions. Can interfere with EMI/RFI transmissions.
VERSATILITY Pigments added to the resin provide color throughout the part. Special colors available. Must be painted for color. To maintain color and corrosion resistance, repainting may be required.
EASY FIELD FABRICATION Pultruded fiberglass can be field fabricated using simple carpenter tools with carbon or diamond tip blades.

Lightweight for easier erection and installation.

Often requires welding and cutting torches.

Heavier material requires special handling equipment to erect and install.

COST Lower installation and maintenance costs in industrial applications often equals lower lifecycle costs. Lower initial material cost.


COPYRIGHT © 2007 - PULTRUSION INDUSTRY COUNCIL